MVPs for 2016

Kris Bryant, circling the bases after one of his 39 home runs, was named National League MVP on Thursday, while Mike Trout (below) earned the same honor in the AL. While there's no questioning their talent or leadership, the context of their selection does come into question. Bryant was a leader of the club with the best regular season record in baseball. He fits the presumed definition of what an MVP should be; then again, what is "Valuable?" Is that a player whose loss might turn a contender into an also ran? Is it an overachiever posting unexpectedly big numbers? Does the award encompass on-field leadership? Responding under pressure? And I like the term "difference maker."
Trout's excellence is unquestioned -- his combination of speed, power and outstanding defense identifies him as one of the today's absolute best players. 29 homers, 100 RBIs, along with leading the majors in runs scored, walks and on-base percentage.
Yet unlike Bryant's Cubs, Trout's Angels were a bad ballclub that didn't play a "meaningful game" after April. He rarely faced the pressure Bryant's Cubs -- or David Ortiz's Red Sox -- did day in/day out. Shouldn't that be a factor? There's a line the beloved Mets broadcaster Ralph Kiner often quoted about Branch Rickey, his GM with the Pirates during the early 1950s: "We could have finished last without you." While Rickey used that as the basis to hold down his slugger's salary, it also fits Trout. How do you judge value on a fourth place club that won all of 74 games? If Trout wasn't there, would they have won 64? 54? Even with the New Jersey-born superstar in the lineup, they far off the pace set by the 1st place Rangers.
If baseball wants to add a new award -- Player of the Year or Most Outstanding Player -- give that one to Trout. But by incorporating the word "Valuable," the voting ought to be weighed in favor of the standout players on contending clubs. For 2016, that means Ortiz, Encarnacion and Santana. They played and delivered under pressure. While you can't blame Trout for the failure of his teammates, I have to judge his season in a somewhat different light. Had I had a vote for MVP, I wouldn't have given it to him.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rare Remnant of a Lost Ballpark

Image
When the subject of baseball in Brooklyn comes up, the discussion centers around Ebbets Field, the Flatbush venue most famously home to The Boys of Summer.  Those legendary 1940s and '50s teams that featured such historic and beloved players as Jackie Robinson, Duke Snider, Pee Wee Reese, Roy Campanella and Gil Hodges. Ebbets Field hosted its last major league game in 1957 and was torn down during the winter of 1960. But decades earlier, just before World War One, the Dodgers were based in the Park Slope area and played at Washington Park.  Once they moved out, the land was occupied by another stadium, which housed a different franchise.  The upstart Federal League, which played in the 1914 and '15 seasons, had a Brooklyn team called the TipTops.  Owned by a local baking magnate Robert Ward, whose company produced TipTop bread, the club took over the abandoned lot along 3rd Avenue and built a new brick and steel venue. The only no-hitter in the Federal League's two...
Read more

Will He Wear Zero in the Bronx?

Image
The Yankees bolstered their starting rotation with Thursday's signing of Marcus Stroman .  The Long Island native, who spent 2019 and '21 with the Mets before moving onto the Cubs, brings a 77-76 career record to the Bronx, along with a recent loyalty to uniform number (?) zero.  If he requests that, he'd become the third Yank to wear it, following the path of Adam Ottavino and Domingo German.  Of course, neither of their Yankee tenures ended all that well -- Ottavino struggled badly in 2020, before reviving his career with the Red Sox and Mets; German's alcohol and domestic violence issues sabotaged such Yankee highlights as last year's perfect game. Can a number truly be lucky? You can understand kids in little league or high school ball wanting to wear 2 in honor of Derek Jeter or 7 for Mickey Mantle.  But is there an heroic ballplayer associated with 0?  The closest I recall comes from pro football, where the Oakland Raiders Hall of Fame center Jim Otto wore...
Read more

Spring Training Flashbacks: Subway Series, Florida Style - 2016

Image
It's a return visit to the Mets' Florida home in Port St. Lucie, this time for a 2016 showdown with the Yankees. (Below), Joe Girardi and Brian Cashman chat during batting practice. Aaron Judge and Rob Refsnyder have their game faces on in the dugout... though neither would be in the starting lineup. (Above) A couple of Brooklyn natives that made their mark in New York baseball -- Lee Mazzilli and John Franco. (Below) Mets pitcher Josh Smoker makes friends by signing a few autographs. (Above) Mets reliever Jeurys Familia; (Below) 2nd baseman Neil Walker (Above) Curtis Granderson, one of the select few players to star for both the Yankees and Mets, getting ready for his third summer at Citi Field. (Below) Aaron Hicks came to the Yankees in a trade the previous November. 3rd baseman Chase Headley enjoying the Grapefruit League vibe, even against Mets ace Jacob deGrom. (Above) Mets slugger Yoenis Cespedes watches where he hit one... so does Joe Girardi from the visitor's dugou...
Read more